If You Understand, You Don’t

Often, I hear peo­ple say to one anoth­er: “Yes, I under­stand.” This phrase can be heard in pri­vate as well as in busi­ness con­ver­sa­tions and every time I ask myself if peo­ple reflect about what they just said.
From a neu­ro­log­i­cal per­spec­tive, to under­stand some­thing means to match that with what is already known by a human being. If you tell me that some­thing has hap­pened because the earth moves around the sun, I’ll accept that and maybe say “I under­stand” since this rela­tion between sun and earth is known to me. So, as long as I use “I under­stand” to express that some­thing approach­ing me match­es some­thing with­in my knowl­edge base, that’s ok.
If “I under­stand” some­thing which is new to me, or incon­sis­tent with my knowl­edge, I rather don’t under­stand that. Since it isn’t actu­al­ly known to me, I can’t under­stand it, but I rather had to learn it. In other words: under­stand­ing means match­ing with the already known, learn­ing means adding or chang­ing (to) the already known.
Why should this dif­fer­en­ti­a­tion be of inter­est for us? Assum­ing that most peo­ple use the expres­sion “I see” or “I under­stand” in the way used above, we should be care­ful if we tell some­thing new to some­body who answers with “Ah, I under­stand”. In this case, I would chal­lenge this ‘under­stand­ing’, since either I haven’t told this per­son some­thing new (opposed to what I thought) or this per­son has­n’t real­ly grasped what I told him.
We know that most prob­lems between human beings result from com­mu­ni­ca­tion defi­cien­cies and I’m con­vinced that espe­cial­ly this ‘under­stand­ing thing’ plays a major role by cre­at­ing a pseu­do atmos­phere of agree­ment and shared assump­tions, val­ues, etc.. If we express our under­stand­ing but have — false­ly — matched some poten­tial new knowl­edge with our exist­ing knowl­edge and by expe­ri­enc­ing the infor­mant bias, we con­scious­ly or uncon­scious­ly add to more mis­un­der­stand­ings.
I per­son­al­ly try not to fall for that bias by ask­ing myself hard whether I real­ly got what some­body just has told me. And more than once the other one react­ed quite irri­tat­ed when I asked him to repeat what he just said in a dif­fer­ent way. Anoth­er good idea is to repeat myself what the other told me, what — sur­prise — shows that in most cases he again rephrased what I repeat­ed. That may sound like a rather philo­soph­i­cal or tir­ing exer­cise but I am con­vinced it does not only help to under­stand but to learn and to enrich my per­son­al knowl­edge base.

One Reply to “If You Understand, You Don’t”

  1. Oh I under­stand. Mean­ing that the phrase has no mean­ing. That it’s just a phrase peo­ple splurt out when they see some­thing famil­iar. Not a phrase of true under­stand­ing. Got it. Took me a while. Nice title, by the way.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



The Mind­ful Rev­o­lu­tion, Michael Reuter

Die Acht­same Rev­o­lu­tion, Michael Reuter

The Idea of the Brain, Matthew Cobb

The Great Men­tal Mod­els I, Shane Par­rish

The Great Men­tal Mod­els II, Shane Par­rish

The Biggest Bluff, Maria Kon­niko­va

Essen Ändert Alles, Hol­ger Stromberg

The Oxy­gen Advan­tage, Patrick McK­e­own

Rewire Your Brain , John B. Arden

The Way of the Ice­man, Koen de Jong

Soft Wired — How The New Sci­ence of Brain Plas­tic­i­ty Can Change Your Life, Michael Merzenich

The Brain That Changes Itself, Nor­man Doidge

Lifes­pan, David Sin­clair

What Does­n’t Kill Us, Scott Car­ney

Suc­cess­ful Aging, Daniel Levithin

The Body Builders, Adam Piore

Der Ernährungskom­pass, Bas Kast

The Way We Eat Now, Bee Wil­son

Dein Gehirn weiss mehr als Du denkst, Niels Bir­baumer

Denken: Wie das Gehirn Bewusst­sein schafft, Stanis­las Dehaene

Mind­ful­ness, Ellen J. Langer

Full Cat­a­stro­phe Liv­ing, Jon Kabat-Zinn

100 Plus: How The Com­ing Age of Longevi­ty Will Change Every­thing, Sonia Arri­son

Think­ing Like A Plant, Craig Hol­dredge

Die Glück­shy­pothese, Jonathan Haidt

Mind Over Med­i­cine, Lissa Rankin

Das Geheime Wis­sen unser­er Zellen, Son­dra Bar­ret

The Code of the Extra­or­di­nary Mind, Vishen Lakhi­ani

Alt wer­den ohne alt zu sein, Rudi Wes­t­en­dorp

Altered Traits, Daniel Cole­man, Richard David­son

The Brain’s Way Of Heal­ing, Nor­man Doidge

The Last Best Cure, Donna Jack­son Nakaza­wa

The Hour Between Dog and Wolf: Risk-taking, Gut Feel­ings and the Biol­o­gy of Boom and Bust, John Coates

The Inner Game of Ten­nis, W. Tim­o­thy Gall­way

Run­ning Lean, Ash Mau­rya

Schlaf wirkt Wun­der, Hans-Günther Weeß

Sleep — Schlafen wie die Profis, Nick Lit­tle­hales